Is a Blackhead Extractor Effective?

Vicky Davis, FNP

Medically reviewed by Katelyn Hagerty, FNP

Written by Our Editorial Team

Last updated 10/1/2021

While not your favorite sight, blackheads are a common type of comedonal acne that can form just about anywhere on your face and body.

They’re caused by a combination of sebum and dead skin cells, which can build up on your skin and clog your pores.

If you’ve looked into treatments for blackheads, you might have seen blackhead extractor tools similar to those used by aestheticians or healthcare professionals, either available online or in your local drug store. 

Blackhead extractors work by physically removing the contents of blackheads. They often do the trick and provide fast results — but can damage your skin and increase your risk of scarring when used incorrectly.

Read on to learn more about blackhead extractors, and whether or not you should include one in your skincare arsenal. 

Below we include details on how they work to get rid of acne, as well as whether or not it’s worth using one at home. 

We’ve also included other science-based ways you can get rid of blackheads, whiteheads and other forms of acne, to avoid scarring and prevent them from coming back. 

What Are Blackhead Extractors?

A blackhead extractor — or comedone extractor — is a small tool designed to remove the contents of comedonal acne.

Acne develops when your hair follicles (pores) become clogged with a combination of sebum and dead skin cells.

Sebum is a type of oil that’s produced by your sebaceous glands. It’s important for moisturizing your skin and maintaining the barrier that protects your skin against infection.

Dead skin cells are produced as a byproduct of your skin’s epidermal turnover process. As new skin cells replace old ones, the dead cells form into an outer layer that’s eventually shed into the environment.

When sebum and dead skin cells produce a clogged pore that’s open to the environment, it can take on a dark color as a result of a process called oxidation, resulting in the classic blackheads that we all occasionally see around our nose, cheeks and elsewhere on our faces.

Blackhead extractors are small instruments that work by physically pushing out the contents of a clogged pore, such as a blackhead. 

Extractor tools are similar in design to a small pencil or nail file and are typically made from stainless steel.

Blackhead Extractor Types

Most blackhead extractors are sold in sets, with a range of different “heads” or “needles” to help you apply pressure to the skin and remove acne. Common types of blackhead extractors include:

  • Round tip extractors. These have a round or looped tip that allows you to easily apply pressure to the skin surrounding a comedone. The round design makes this type of tool easy to use on small and medium-sized blackheads. Many acne extractor sets include small or large angled and flat-loop tools to press against acne lesions of different sizes.

  • Spoon extractor. Also referred to as a comedone spoon, this type of tool features a tiny spoon at its tip with one or several holes. When pressed against the skin, the contents of a clogged pore can be extracted into the spoon for easy removal.

  • Lancet extractor. This type of tool features a sharp lancet for popping blackheads, with an extractor at the other end for removing sebum and dead skin cells. This type of tool is designed for larger forms of comedonal acne.

  • Acne tweezers. These feature curved, sharp tips that are designed to apply pressure to the skin and remove the contents of comedones. They’re often used to treat stubborn or large blackheads that can’t be removed with a round tip extractor.

  • Blackhead vacuum. Also referred to as a pore vacuum, this type of tool attaches to the skin and sucks out the contents of a blocked pore. Some blackhead vacuums include a range of heads, or probes, to remove comedones of different sizes.

Most blackhead extractors are affordable. You can find multi-tool sets online and in many health and beauty stores for as little as $10 to $50 or more. 

Blackhead vacuums are typically available for $25 to approximately $100, depending on the specific model and features. 

Acne Treatment

Wanna get acne in check? We got you.

Should You Extract Blackheads at Home?

Because blackhead extractors are inexpensive and seemingly easy to use, extracting your acne at home seems like a no brainer. 

The thing is, though: Acne extraction is much more difficult than it looks. Even with a set of blackhead extractor tools, it’s surprisingly easy to damage your skin and either leave behind scars or make your acne breakouts worse.

There are several reasons using a blackhead extractor could scar skin. The first is that proper acne extraction involves removing the entire contents of a pimple — which is harder than it seems. 

When you extract acne at home, you may remove part of a blackhead’s contents, yet push the rest deeper into your skin. 

This may rupture the follicle wall and cause your acne to become inflamed, swollen and painful.

It’s also possible to spread bacteria from your acne toolkit into your pores, which can cause your pimples to develop into painful and severe infected acne

Even when at-home acne extraction doesn’t make your breakouts worse, it may harm your skin and increase your risk of developing acne dark spots and permanent scars.

Because of these risks, it’s almost always better to leave your blackheads alone than to attempt to extract them at home. 

Better Ways to Treat Blackheads

While using a blackhead extractor at home usually isn’t a good idea, there are several safe and effective ways you can get rid of blackheads and prevent them from coming back.

Get Acne Extracted Professionally

If you have lots of small blackheads or a few severe ones, you might want to have them removed professionally. 

A healthcare professional can specialize in treating acne and other skin conditions, and will use sterile equipment to safely and effectively extract even the most stubborn blackheads without any damage to your skin. 

For severe forms of acne, such as nodular acne and cystic acne, your healthcare provider might suggest using medication to reduce acne swelling and speed up the healing process.

In addition to acne extraction, many healthcare providers offer other procedures to get rid of acne and clear your skin, such as chemical peels and microdermabrasion

These can also help to smooth out wrinkles, lighten acne scars and improve common issues such as skin discoloration. 

Wash Your Face with an Acne-Specific Cleanser

If you seem to have acne-prone skin, one of the best things you can do to stop blackheads and other acne lesions from forming is to wash your face with a high-quality cleanser. 

Facial cleansers are designed to strip away excess oil and skin cells, and often contain active ingredients such as benzoyl peroxide and salicylic acid, which help stop bacteria and dead skin cells from clogging your pores and causing acne breakouts.

If you have sensitive skin, you may want to consider a cleanser that’s made using gentler active ingredients, such as Hers Deep Sea Cleanser for Acne

Adding a cleanser to your daily skin care routine is an easy way to get rid of existing blackheads while preventing new acne from developing. 

Use Topical Acne Medication

For a more effective reduction in blackheads, consider adding a topical acne medication to your acne prevention toolkit.

Several topical medications can be used to treat acne. When it comes to effectiveness and ease of use, it’s difficult to beat topical retinoids such as tretinoin, which works by improving your skin’s ability to produce new cells and preventing pores from becoming clogged with debris.

Tretinoin is great at preventing future blackheads from developing, and as a bonus, also has anti-aging benefits, making it great for stopping fine lines and wrinkles from affecting your skin. 

You can access tretinoin with other proven, science-based ingredients in Hers Prescription Acne Cream and Prescription Acne Cream for Teens

customized acne treatment

clear skin or your money back

Using a Blackhead Extractor: Worth It?

Blackhead extractors are cheap and easy to find online, but using them to get rid of your acne at home isn’t recommended.

While blackhead removal might seem easy, using a blackhead extractor tool without the proper technique can damage your skin and worsen acne breakouts

It can also cause infection, inflammation and even permanent scars.

For better results, stick to proven acne treatments or contact a healthcare provider to have your acne extracted professionally. 

If you’d like more information on how to treat acne, check out this guide to the best science-based acne treatments, which explains how you can get rid of stubborn blackheads, whiteheads and other forms of acne and maintain clear, blemish-free skin for good.

9 Sources

Hims & Hers has strict sourcing guidelines to ensure our content is accurate and current. We rely on peer-reviewed studies, academic research institutions, and medical associations. We strive to use primary sources and refrain from using tertiary references.

  1. Sutaria, A.H., Masood, S. & Schlesinger, J. (2021, August 9). Acne Vulgaris. StatPearls. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK459173/
  2. Hoover, E., Aslam, S. & Krishnamurthy, K. (2020, October 26). Physiology, Sebaceous Glands. StatPearls. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK499819/
  3. Koster, M.I. (2009, July). Making an epidermis. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. 1170, 7–10. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2861991/
  4. Acne. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.americanskin.org/resource/acne.php
  5. Pimple Popping: Why Only a Dermatologist Should Do It. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://www.aad.org/public/diseases/acne/skin-care/popping
  6. Benzoyl Peroxide Topical. (2015, August 15). Retrieved from https://medlineplus.gov/druginfo/meds/a601026.html
  7. Salicylic Acid Topical. (2016, September 15). Retrieved from https://medlineplus.gov/druginfo/meds/a607072.html
  8. Yoham, A.L. & Casadesus, D. (2020, December 5). Tretinoin. StatPearls. Retrieved from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK557478/
  9. Tretinoin Topical. (2019, March 15). Retrieved from https://medlineplus.gov/druginfo/meds/a682437.html

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. The information contained herein is not a substitute for and should never be relied upon for professional medical advice. Always talk to your doctor about the risks and benefits of any treatment.

📫 Get updates from hims

Insider tips, early access and more.

Want to learn more?

Adult acne does not have to be your new normal. Learn about how these dermatologist prescribed solutions can work for you here.